Skip to main content

Why Mumbai will never be free from traffic

2004 : Regular commute on the western express highway (which was barely a total of 3-4 lanes) all the way to Seepz, sometimes via Aarey Colony/JVLR.
Chai pe discussions (borrowed phrase) over why are they bothering to build a highway in the middle of the city..why we just cant have a metro from Ghodbundar / Kashimira to atleast Bandra, since we were anyways building the commercial district of Bandra Kurla Complex and the Bandra Terminus.
Anyways Delhi had a metro since the 1990's, and we being the hip and happening Mumbai deserved our own.
That, we all know did not happen.

And, in the meanwhile, atleast I now have good understanding of why something like that or similar will have opposing forces :
  • Lost Fare - Such a move would render thousands of auto fares/taxi fares needless. Think about Rs. 1 to 2 crore lost on a daily basis. In this context, think of the cycle of increasing taxi-auto fares -> increasing taxi/auto permits -> increasing fares -> you get the idea..
  • Auto Rickshaw manufacturing - Generally such a loss in fare would result in a lower number of people entering this profession, resulting in about 5-7% vehicles lesser on the road. That is lost revenue for a total of approximately 7000 (autos + taxis) lost, which is in turn a loss of a similar amount or a little lesser number of loans for the banks. About Rs. 30-40 crore gone.
  • Fuel Consumption - Obviously, without saying, lesser vehicles lead to lesser fuel consumption.. atleast another Rs. 6 lakh on a daily basis lost.
  • Road Construction - what would we do without these guys and all these flyovers zig-zagging..and ah yes the monsoon..that would be sooo boring.
  • Politics - Some of these autos, from what I know are owned by the juniormost level politicos - 5-6 per such politico, used as a dole for the underlings...
  • Rent Seeking - The permit economy of about Rs. 1 lakh per auto for about 3 years and Rs. 1.5 lakh for a cab permit is another lost opportunity.
  • Politics again - Approximately 7-8 lakh adults, including the drivers and their families rely on this profession. 
  • Cars - Seriously, how many of you would drive or bother to purchase a car if I gave you the option to sit and commute comfortably to your office. So with the cars, is the impact on the car companies and obviously is the fuel.
  • Jobs - With the cars lost, obviously, a conservative estimate of another 1000-2000 personal chaffeurs become jobless.
In short, this is a trade off between the comfort of the largely educate middle class + the business class, against the employment of the lower middle class. In short, re-distribution/socialistic policies.

What is wrong/right, I do not know.. but this is definitely an example of what is coming next..
The big debate of employment vs technology or the technology endgame... and how the demographic dividend may not exist.





    Comments

    Anonymous said…
    An interesting experiment in demand, supply and pricing would be -

    1. Find optimum number of vehicles required for city limits, population, commuters

    2. Increase fares of public transportation like auto, cabs.

    3. Increase number of cabs and autos.

    4. Repeat 2 and 3 till visible decrease seen in commuters.

    Popular posts from this blog

    Body Guard

    Ok, So one of the channels decided to show BodyGuard at 9 pm. yesterday. Had heard the movie wasn't that great. Had found Wanted crazily hilarious, so switched to the movie sharp at 9 pm.  The movie started with a scene localized for consumption from Rajneeti (Sorry, Rajneeti localized GodFather, and now Rajneeti gets a mention.) Why on earth would they start a movie like this ? Well that was it. The movie lost 80% of my interest then. Still hung around even though most of the going ons were nonsense. Finally switched channels when Salman Khan did a SpiderMan (no it was Robot) to jump out of the local train onto an express going in the opposite direction. Good thing the jump was before 13 Nov 2011, else, post the switchover happening today from DC to AC, a man standing on the train is likely to be pulled into the overhead wires. Last thing, please change the name of the movie to Body-Spider-Father-Man !! Sounds dumb ? That's how the start looked to me. Disclaimer:...

    Yennovation, Monopoly

    I have been wondering, and Yes, I do know that I do that a lot !! Wondering, about Dominant Design. An alternative name for a Monopoly !!  No, not a monopoly in the orthodox sense of an enterprise, but the monopoly of a particular dominant design. Why do we have only electricity and no other 'city' after that. A random google search (what else ) tells me humanity has known electricity for over 2500 years, analyzed and have been capable of generating it for almost 300 years. But isn't someone trying to discover an alternate form of powering us up instead of just alternate forms of electricity generation methods !! Dont we loose a lot in transformation ?? What about wheels. Sure it maybe 1 of the most important discoveries / inventions ever, but doesnt anyone think of changing the fundamentals of transport. Arent we advanced enough to stop having wheels as the dominant design. What about planes that jump up like a frog, instead of the runway, before t...